N
Glam Monitor

Is Sidney Crosby better than Mario Lemieux?

Author

David Perry

Updated on August 12, 2026

Crosby can realistically surpass Lemieux as the all-time leader, however, it won't happen in as many games. Sid has already competed in 864 games whereas Mario finished his career with 915, retiring with a ridiculous 1.88 points/ per game.

Who is the greatest Pittsburgh Penguin of all time?

Sidney Crosby

One of the greatest to ever play the game, both on and off the ice. A pillar of hockey. not just for the Penguins, but for the City of Pittsburgh since his arrival in 2005. It has been his play over the last 15+ years that has set Crosby apart from so many others.

Is Mario Lemieux the best hockey player of all time?

Lemieux boasted a combination of physical skills unmatched in the history of hockey. His effortless stride, exceptional hands and extraordinary reach made him the best one-on-one player ever. Like a maestro, he artfully dictated the tempo of the world's fastest game.

Is Crosby better than Gretzky?

According to Hockey-Reference.com, Gretzky was on the ice for 70 power-play goals that season, which is 61 percent more than Crosby, who was on for 43 last season.

Who is the greatest hockey player ever?

Wayne Gretzky shattered long-standing records, notably scoring an unprecedented 894 goals. He also earned four Stanley Cups with the Edmonton Oilers (1984–85, 1987–88) and was named the NHL's MVP nine (!) times (1980–87, 1989).

18 related questions found

Who is better Sidney Crosby or Ovechkin?

Not only does Pittsburgh own 12 more wins against the Capitals, Crosby has been the better player by a significant margin. The Penguins superstar has 24 more points than Ovechkin in career head-to-head matchups, averaging 1.377 points per game in comparison to Ovi's 0.984.

Who is better Wayne Gretzky or Mario Lemieux?

Gretzky is widely regarded as the greatest player in NHL history and holds nearly every possible offensive record. Lemieux has the second-highest points-per-game rate in history and appeared in less than 1,000 games but remains one of the best to ever play.

Is Mario Lemieux the goat?

The NHL's true GOAT is none other than “The Magnificent One” Mario Lemieux. The case starts here: Lemieux's 1.883 points per game has him second on the NHL's all-time list, just . 038 behind Gretzky in first and .

Is Sidney Crosby the goat?

Crosby combines career achievement, having won almost every trophy possible, and a vast skillset, besting Gretzky in numerous areas even without the video game scoring numbers. Sid may not take the “Great One” title, but he deserves to be considered the GOAT.

Did Sidney Crosby play with Mario Lemieux?

Crosby Lived With Mario Lemieux

When Crosby was first drafted by the Penguins in 2005, fans hoped that he could go on to have a career as successful as Hall-Of-Famer Mario Lemieux. Interestingly enough, the two were briefly teammates, as Lemieux's final season came during Crosby's rookie year.

Is Crosby elite?

Sidney Crosby has lifted his game back to an elite level after stop-and-start beginning | Pittsburgh Post-Gazette.

Why is Crosby so good?

Speed. Crosby has a powerful stride for a smaller player. His ability to zip around the ice helps get him extra chances, whether they are around the net or by sliding in to open areas.

Who is the goat of hockey?

Wayne Gretzky

The NHL record book might as well be renamed “The Memoirs of Wayne Gretzky”, as he basically wrote it himself throughout his career. The only player in NHL history to record 200 points in a single season, Gretzky achieved the feat a whopping four times during his career.

Is McDavid better than Gretzky?

Hockey-Reference.com's adjusted points stat rates McDavid's 2020-21 campaign ahead of Gretzky's 1981-82 season, in which Gretzky scored 212 unadjusted points, the second-highest single-season points total in league history. McDavid is — how do you say — very good at hockey.

How many seasons did Mario Lemieux miss?

Lemieux was the only bright spot for the Penguins when he was drafted. The Penguins missed the playoffs in Lemieux's first four seasons, despite Lemieux scoring over 100 points in each season.

Is Gretzky the greatest hockey player of all time?

On Jan. 9, 1998, Gretzky is named the Greatest Hockey Player of All-Time as selected by The Hockey News. Gretzky tallies three points (one goal, two assists) in the North America All-Stars' 8-6 victory over the World All-Stars on Jan.

What made Gretzky so good?

1. Versatility and athleticism: Gretzky was versatile in a demanding and rugged team sport. Hockey focuses on a myriad of athletic attributes—many of the same varied skills utilized, for the most part, by basketball, football and soccer players, widely considered among the best athletes.

Who has scored 700 goals in the NHL?

Hats off to Alex Ovechkin for notching his 700th goal

Wayne Gretzky (894), Gordie Howe (801), Jaromir Jagr (766), Brett Hull (741), Marcel Dionne (731), Phil Esposito (717) and Mike Gartner (708) are the other players to score 700 NHL goals.

Is Sidney Crosby good at defense?

Crosby is certainly decent enough in his own end, but hasn't really shown exceptional defensive results. And that's not even a negative, if he's digging too deep defensively, he's not in position to lead transition attacks — where he's undoubtedly at his most dangerous.

Is Sidney Crosby good?

Crosby was the youngest player to score 100 points in a season and youngest to win the scoring title. He's sixth all-time in points per game among players with 500 or more games played, and he's third all-time among those who reached 1,000 games.